My mistake Joe, the New Castle number was indeed not including shipping, making BoardTracker Harley the best deal. So here are the new numbers:
(part numbers 67800367, hardware and 68000172 bulbs the smoked version should be same price):
(not including Tax, which you wouldn't pay unless you get them at your local dealer or live in the same state as any of these online dealers)
MSRP: $829.90
Surdyke: $749.22 (no shipping)
NewCastle: $702.67 (includes $49.95 in shipping)
BoardTracker: 688.00 (no shipping)
All of this good info led me to a local dealer who had them in stock and sold them to me for $700 out the door, tax included. $12 more than board tracker and $100 more than the used set, but I really wanted to install them for the weekend and I wanted new. Thanks all for the great info, saved me a couple hundred bucks!