I made the mistake of test riding an Indian. Apples to apples (stock HD 103 vs. stock Indian 111) there was no comparison. Better suspension, power plant, etc.. Smooth delivery of power... Sure, compared to a CVO and it gets closer... But now we're talking 10-15k more in price point. Looks are subjective, I get that... I happen to think that Victory is butt ugly... But the Indian is gorgeous in my mind. Again, all subjective.
Many are afraid to admit it, but the Indian was the best thing that ever happened to HD... They've gotten away with selling us cr@p for way too long. I'm hoping my beloved motor company gets off their a$$. And please don't ride the Indian... Because you'll either own one, or lie to yourself aboutw why you're continuing to spend money on such an inferior piece of technology.