JCZ:
I don't commute that much with my SERK, but my truck tires get a work out.
Based on the layout of the freeway that I drive to work and the exit/on ramps, 90% of my turns are to the right. I also tend to drive quite fast on them either exiting or getting up to speed getting back onto the freeway. One might think that all the turns are just reversed on the return route, but with the exit/on ramps some being left on or right on tends to throw the mix to one direction of turn more than the other.
Over the MANY years I've been able to think about things, I remember that when a wee little tike, I tried to learn to snow ski. During those very early years I could turn to the left, but not to the right. Even roller skating a lot in my younger days or ice skating, I could slide/skid to the left, but not the right. Let me mention that I'm right handed.
When practicing with the SERK on 180 U-turns on two lane roads, I always turn to the left. I can turn to the right, but I don't feel as comfortable doing it. Without reading the link that was posted, but using my own thought process, I'd say that I tend to carve harder to the left than the right and that may add to my tire wear at some time.
Now with all that crap I just said, you state a good point in that your previous tires on the same route did NOT exhibit the same left tire side wear.
I have the new Avon Cobra tires on my new board track project and they are co-extruded with the hard rubber in the middle and softer rubber on the sides. This is supposed to give longer highway miles and still grab on the turns, at least that's how I read the text.
I deal with extruders a lot in my area of expertise, my real job, I can see how the process could get out of phase and cause a batch of out of processed tires that could do what you're explaining.
Sorry for the rambling, but I just always thought as a kid it was funny how a right handed person tends to turn left better and the left handed person starts turning better to the right. After years of practice and being on the National Ski Patrol for many years, I got what I would call very proficient in both directions, so lots of practice does pay off. Now to start turning more to the right on the bike.
