Alright, I labored long and hard on this decision. I called and talked to the folks at DK, Pro-Action, and SuperShox. I also took into account the input here on CVOHarley.com and some Youtube reviews. Ohlins were definitely in the running.
The folks at Pro-Action felt they had a better shock than the Ohlin 159 but they relented that the Ohlin Reservoir shock outperformed them by a bit (5-10%, however that would be measured). They had no opinion on the SuperShox line. The folks at DK, who use Pro-Action 14", thought the SuperShox was a fine product line.
All said and done, I decided upon the SuperShox Platinum Series LT 14" that has an MSRP of $1300. JCZ and BigChuck got me considering that mfg seriously and then talking to Brian G at SuperShox put me over the top. This is the top of the line Super Shox offers and it's similar to the Ohlin's HD852.
I tried to stay in my $600-$1000 target. I exceeded it by just a bit. $1075 including shipping from Horny Toad HD after talking to Reginald Harris.