Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Boatman]

At home, we currently have a Windows 98 computer.  Some new programs on CD's won't run.  Don't do anything high tech with it, not that computer literate.  Lucky to post a picture in a post.

If I were to purchase a new desk top, would you get XP Home, XP Pro, or some sort of Vista?  Have never used a Mac..  Like I stated, don't use most of the features of this one.

If you prefer XP, is the Pro worth the additional money?

Thanks in advance, Bob..

[HogDude]

At home, we currently have a Windows 98 computer.  Some new programs on CD's won't run.  Don't do anything high tech with it, not that computer literate.  Lucky to post a picture in a post.

If I were to purchase a new desk top, would you get XP Home, XP Pro, or some sort of Vista?  Have never used a Mac..  Like I stated, don't use most of the features of this one.

If you prefer XP, is the Pro worth the additional money?

Thanks in advance, Bob..

Bob,
If it were me, I would go with XP Home...... Nothing wrong with Pro, just don't know if the few extra goodies are needed for a true home environment.
I have 3 systems at home with XP Home and 2 at the office running XP Professional.

Personally, I would stay away from Vista... still too many incompatibilities with drivers, etc. at this point in time. IMHO

Your mileage may vary.
Good Luck

[Fired00d]

Running XP Pro (just because they came w/computers) on all computers (3) except one laptop at home that has Vista on it. Not that familiar w/Vista and what I have seen don't really like it, but that could be the fact that I'm more use to XP. Like HogDude mentioned I've heard of issues w/Vista and would probably wait a year or so until I would upgrade if I had to.

 
Ride Safe,
Fired00d
 

[BayouBiker]

without a doubt - go with XP Pro!

[rlavigna]

Buy the XP Pro SP2 edition as it includes better connectivity functions for home and/or business networks than XP Home.  Vista is stable enough now but I see no compelling reason to get Vista yet.

[Unbalanced]

I highly doubt you can buy a machine unless you have it built without it coming with Vista on it.   

[Boatman]

I highly doubt you can buy a machine unless you have it built without it coming with Vista on it.   

On some of Dell's desktops, you can still get XP or Pro..  I was playing around on Dell's site building computers, found that XP was still available, and started the questioning process.  May be the time to buy while you can still get the XP??

[Unbalanced]

A friend of ours ordred one with XP Pro on it from Dell and got Vista.    /shrug     I would tell you if your not an permissions / security person with Windows you will find Vista frustrating.   

[Fired00d]

On some of Dell's desktops, you can still get XP or Pro..  I was playing around on Dell's site building computers, found that XP was still available, and started the questioning process.  May be the time to buy while you can still get the XP??

I just saw that on the Dell site also and checked Gateway and they are still offering XP Pro also.

 
Ride Safe,
Fired00d
 

[RedBone]

This is what I do for living buy sell build and repair laptops and desktops Xp pro the one  :nervous:to go for at the moment both for compatability and ease of use need any further help PM me

[Kevinski]

my 2 cents, if you have old software that is not compatable with Vista, then go for XP. If you just have the one machine then XP home is fine.

I have been running the release version of Vista since November 2006 as a MSDN subscriber, running on a desktop and also a new HP tablet and find it rock solid. I still have XP on one desktop and my video editting software (Sony Vegas) is not compatable with Vista and I object to have to buy an upgrade to run on Vista.

If you are buying a new machine Vista Home Premium seems the best value and you can upgrade to the Ultimate edition later if you want. Vista is going to be in support longer than XP which also means you will save money in the long term.

Cheers,

Kev

[Break-In]

did some testing at work with Vista, better off with XP Pro

[ccr]

We just got (Nov) a new computer and there did not seem to be anything except Vista available when we were shopping.  We have the Windows Vista Home Premium version.  Other than a slight learning curve on some of the new Microsoft Office software that we bought and loaded, it works pretty good. We fought for a few hours with trying to set up the network ---- finally paid the Geek Squad to come out.  They hooked up our old XP computer, printer, external hard drive, the Wii game player and the new computer to the network and made sure they all work.  Now there is no issue doing anything. The only problem we are having with the laptop, is every now and then it fails to find the router, then we have to do a reboot.  Seems to be that this happens after an update, just we don't get a message saying this it the issue. 

We bought the HP Pavilion dv9628nr. 

[rednectum]

agree with the xp home, or pro if you want more securities, home is more than robust enough for the average joe.

have been adding ram to friends computers that run vista, vista is a genuine resouce hog---still sluggish with a gig of ram. also cant clicky-clicky fast enough to get through all the idiot proofinf. vista asks "are you sure you wanna do this?" whenever you try to open/ add/ change something.

you can get xp boxes at tigerdirrect.com. just look at refurbs, theses are great machines and you save coin.

[SneakyPete]

Ok this is where I break from the group.  I would seriously consider the iMAC.  My son has been telling me for many months the MAC is superior to any PC, less complicated for non-geeks (like me), more flexible and user friendly.  He owns one and I have used it and I must agree with him.  Wish I had listened to him before buying this POS PC laptop I am using now.  Go to a Best Buy and try it then compare to PC and see what you think.   

[grc]

Here's my two cents (which is worth pretty much zilch after inflation):  Unless you just have to have the latest visual effects and irritating security features, stick with XP Pro SP2.  Vista has been a major disappointment to the computing public as well as to Microsoft (similar to the MoCo's "upgrade" to the 110, if you know what I mean), and has led many computer companies to continue to offer XP on their custom built PC's.  Vista is just one more example of what many call "bloatware", software that is overly complicated and requires too many system resources.  XP runs fine on a machine with 512 MB of RAM, but Vista requires 1024 MB minimum just to run with all the visual features enabled.  Decent performance requires even more RAM, more like 2048 MB (2 GB).

As for the support issue, Microsoft will continue to support XP with security updates for the foreseeable future.  Support is also available through non-Microsoft sites and forums for user issues.  In a couple of years, maybe MS will get their act together and come out with a decent operating system and you can upgrade at that time.  Or you may want to move to Linux and get off the Bill Gates bloatware train.  And Pete also offers an excellent idea; the Apple (Mac) is an excellent system for anyone not heavily invested in Windows experience and software.  

Jerry

[Spoiled!]

I'm with the majority here XP Pro SP2 - it is proven and works. Vista has too many bugs right now for me to even consider it. As stated before Microsoft will continue to support it for a while and there are so many XP user forums out there that you should have no problems finding help with it if needed.

I would like to see a MAC in action though. I have never used one and have only heard good things about them.

Just my $0.02 

Kathy

[WVULTRA]

This is what I do for living buy sell build and repair laptops and desktops Xp pro the one  :nervous:to go for at the moment both for compatability and ease of use need any further help PM me

I agree with RedBone!  As a self-builder for many years, have to say XP Pro is the finest OS Microsoft has ever offered.

I would demand the supplier install XP, and if they refuse find one that will.  Vista may be the OS of the future once a few service packs are out.  Or it could become the next Windows ME!

My $0.02 worth.

[Boatman]

Thanks everyone for their replies.  Like Bluefelix, I have no Mac experience.  (Talk to 2Lane, he'll say I don't even have Windows experience).       I also thought about Vista being compared to the 110 MOCO as GRC stated. 

[murphy]

Lots of problems and complaints with Vista... we have XP.

If we were buying a new one, I would go see a Mac demo... have heard nothing but good things about them!

Might be worth the 15 minutes if you have the time.

[Midnight Rider]

Bob...I'm running XP Pro on all my machines (home desktop, laptop, Suzanne's laptop), and the IT professionals in my office (UAB, so they are very concerned about system stability and security) will not touch Vista with a 10 foot pole right now.  I've just heard of too many issues right now with Vista to feel comfortable with it.

[LRebel]

I will just echo what most everyone has said; Go with XP. 
I have 7 computers here in my office.  I have a new laptop that has Vista - 3 running XP Pro - 2 running 2000 - and even one still running 98.  XP is by far the most user friendly and stable operating system.  And like someone else said, XP is compatible with some of the older programs/drivers that you may still want to use.  I have a client/friend that is a computer geek for FAA - he writes flight simulator programs.  He told me that Vista is a memory hog...He also said that the FAA will not buy computers with Vista.
We are going to finally have to replace the old computer that is running 98 in the next week or so and I have already checked on ordering a new one from Dell with XP Pro.

[SneakyPete]

Just a point of clarification, the iMac will run windows programs.

[harleyteam]

my father just ordered a dell and paid $60 extra for the xp to be put in.  so, it's still available

[Boatman]

Ordered a new Dell desktop today with XP Pro..  Again, thanks to everyone who responded and looked.  Bob

[VAZHOG]

Ok this is where I break from the group.  I would seriously consider the iMAC.  My son has been telling me for many months the MAC is superior to any PC, less complicated for non-geeks (like me), more flexible and user friendly.  He owns one and I have used it and I must agree with him.  Wish I had listened to him before buying this POS PC laptop I am using now.  Go to a Best Buy and try it then compare to PC and see what you think.   

I agree with you!   

I have been a Dell user since Jan 0f 2001 and kept my Pentium 3 Win2000 box running until the mother board passed away this past October. I upgraded to a Second Dell box with Xp in 2002 and then a Dell Laptop in 2004 with XP.

All are networked and are on a UPS my desktops stay up 24/7, all are running Ad watch, and Spybot and I’ve been a Mcafee user since 1994 and have never been infected on any of my machines.

My take on Vista is its windows ME the Microsoft version that came after win 98 it had more problems than solutions to get to the same spot.

The Mac with open source office is all you really need to surf and bill pay and email which about the entire app’s the average user needs.

Since Windows XP it’s trickier  maintain your pc (hardware) wise after it gets some age on it, but it can be done. I changed (upgraded) my Hard Drive about every three years and with XP having built in a hardware finger print you cannot just take the Hard drive out and put it another box, like it can with win 2000, I took my old drive and put it in a Pentium 4 box changed one driver (video) and I was back up and running.

I changed my laptop HD found a nice program and a larger drive online it copied the whole drive over and then all I had to do was swap the drives, and then use the enclosure with my old drive as a USB 80 Meg storage disk. Took all of 30 min. to complete.

If anyone needs any help or suggestions PM me and maybe we can get you back up and running or keep you running once your HD fails its way too late to recover any lost files or memories.