Greg, the automotive tape will not work because it's used for heat resistance around the pipes. As stated, the only reason I used the Ceramic blanket material is to keep it from melting...Even if you used the Kiln rope you would have to wrap it loosely or you'd defeat the purpose. Automotive tape is for a slightly different application, but hey, if you think it will work for you then try it...it's cheap as you stated.
After 5000 miles, the stock insulation starts to disintegrate if you upset it in the tube.
If you were to wrap automotive tape around the baffle it would be like having a straight pipe from the end of the header to the back of the muffler. It would absorb nothing and just be an extension of the header.
bbrown, Any insulation in your Samson baffle will help quiet it down and will not effect performance. You can buy muffler insulation at any metric bike shop. You can do the same process in the pictures above with your stock baffle.
My buddy and I just did it to a D&D Fat cat 2 into 1 system...toned it down significantly...