I continue to be baffled by the Victory / Indian styling philosophy, but perhaps I'm simply not the target audience.
As others have said, the Dark Horse is definitely not my cup of tea. I appreciate the original Indians for what they are: a snapshot in time of what was at its time great styling. The fusion of those orginal styling lines and features like fender skirts with the newer engine and component shapes is just not something that I find at all attractive. Pretty much all of the Indian's fall into this trap.
Of course, I'm also one of those people who thought BMW nailed the perfect sport touring look with it's 2004 R1150RT and then lost their minds and "Bangled" the RT by removing the subtle contours with sharp edges and a frontal view that looked like an owl. Of course, an owl is a hell of a lot better than Bozo the clown!
Hmm, this all has the makings of a blog entry...