Hey there,
Was a frequent member over at Road King Riders myself before I bought my SEEG. This is a great forum, hope you stick around.
As for MSRP, it can be had if you do your homework. However, I've seen worse than the price you mention. HD stealership here had their grand opening yesterday and the red SEEG on the floor was marked $34, 995 plus tax. There is only one dealer in this area that will do MSRP and the waiting list is long. I would take a quick look around for MSRP but if that's the bike you want, I sure wouldn't let $1700 stop you. If he gives you the same trade-in, stock or 95, pull the 95 kit for sure...bet you can sell it on Ebay for that $1700 or like you said, upgrade your other bike basically for free.
As for the SEEG, it is the best HD I've owned and I've had a few...Road King was sweet but this engine/bike is the best Harley has ever made, IMO. And if you start adding up the cost of the motor and chrome upgrades on this bike (103" kit alone is $4000 in the wish book, then add the labor to install it) it doesn't take long to get to the purchase price. Difference is, you pay for the mods up front and their warrantied. It's all good. By the way, that candy red ROCKS...almost as pretty as Starlite Black and Cobalt Blue. [smiley=huepfenjump3.gif]
good luck,
elvis