www.CVOHARLEY.com

CVO Technical => Milwaukee-Eight => Topic started by: acevtwin on July 25, 2017, 03:17:09 PM

Title: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: acevtwin on July 25, 2017, 03:17:09 PM
I have a friend with a Non CVO 2017 Streetglide and she just had a Lifter fail in her 107. It has 5,234 miles on it and had just rode up to Michigan from Florida. She was spending a few days here riding around seeing friends when it happened. Lucky to not be on the Highway somewhere.
Anyone else have this happen on a 114?
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: Toofast_28 on July 25, 2017, 06:06:26 PM
So it begins... Millions of miles of testing and they still can't make stuff that lasts. Hope this is an anomaly, but given the history no one will be surprised if it's the norm.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: grc on July 25, 2017, 07:00:04 PM

They are still using the "C" lifters in the M8 engines, so you can't expect different results.  Harley would obviously rather accept a higher failure rate with the cheap and low quality lifters than spend a little more for a high quality part.  Nothing surprising about that, they've been doing it with a lot of other stuff as well and people keep buying the product.

Jerry
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: mark on August 01, 2017, 10:13:55 AM
Just how much could it cost a company that's purchasing about 750k lifters a year (if my math is correct) to upgrade?  $25 a bike, if that?  Tack that onto the sticker price and move on.  When the last of us baby boomers move on to assisted living, HD is going to be holding its crank in its hand, wondering what happened.   
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: coloradotom on August 01, 2017, 10:34:10 AM
This is getting ridiculous.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: J.D. on August 01, 2017, 11:45:32 AM
Any dealer will tell you the service dept keeps the doors open, and there's no money in super reliable bikes.  :drummer:
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: coloradotom on August 01, 2017, 12:02:55 PM
Any dealer will tell you the service dept keeps the doors open, and there's no money in super reliable bikes.  :drummer:

Well warranty work is not book time. And if warranty work paid dealers their actual labor rate HD would be bankrupt.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: J.D. on August 01, 2017, 12:04:27 PM
"Most" will need service outside of the warranty period.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: rigidthumper on August 01, 2017, 12:07:06 PM
Just how much could it cost a company that's purchasing about 750k lifters a year (if my math is correct) to upgrade?  $25 a bike, if that?  Tack that onto the sticker price and move on.  When the last of us baby boomers move on to assisted living, HD is going to be holding its crank in its hand, wondering what happened.   
I asked Tony N. years ago about that exact thing: He told me they fight with the bean counters over 1/2 of one cent/unit, and some battles were fought better in the SE/accessory catalogs than the production line.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: charles05663 on August 01, 2017, 12:10:56 PM
I asked Tony N. years ago about that exact thing: He told me they fight with the bean counters over 1/2 of one cent/unit, and some battles were fought better in the SE/accessory catalogs than the production line.

This because the SE/Accessory Catalog is a bonus sales to the price of the bike.  It does not affect production costs.
 :oops: :nixweiss:
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: muddypaws on August 01, 2017, 02:34:09 PM
I just hit 10,000 and so far so good. Other ten a new oil pump and a new speedometer that leaked.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: ultrarider123 on August 01, 2017, 02:43:41 PM
I just hit 10,000 and so far so good. Other than a new oil pump and a new speedometer that leaked.

Ok, everybody all at once in one accord with full voice yell this North toward Milwaukee "THEY ALL DO THAT".... :huepfenlol2: :bananarock: ;D
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: Twolanerider on August 01, 2017, 05:30:22 PM
I just hit 10,000 and so far so good. Other ten a new oil pump and a new speedometer that leaked.


The speedometer leaked  :huepfenlol2: ?


What came out of it (did it leak miles so the odometer ran backwards?)?
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: J.D. on August 01, 2017, 06:47:37 PM
I heard the dealer tell a guy (brand new bike) "go park it out in the sun for awhile".
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: tazmun on August 03, 2017, 06:42:02 PM

The speedometer leaked  :huepfenlol2: ?


What came out of it (did it leak miles so the odometer ran backwards?)?

I was going to ask the same question!
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: grc on August 03, 2017, 07:22:16 PM

I'm surprised you guys don't know about the long time issues Harley has had with moisture in gauges (and electrical connections, turn signals, Tour Paks and bags, and other nonessential stuff).  Moisture was "leaking" into Bill's speedometer, enough to leave stains, and it had to be replaced.  It's an all too common issue, especially on a vehicle supposedly designed to be able to handle riding in inclement weather.  I'm sure the new CEO is going to insist his team finally fix this stuff.

Jerry ;)
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: phato1 on August 03, 2017, 07:30:11 PM

The speedometer leaked  :huepfenlol2: ?


What came out of it (did it leak miles so the odometer ran backwards?)?

Maybe that's why there are so many low mileage bikes out there ??? :nixweiss:
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: sadunbar on August 03, 2017, 07:57:18 PM
I don't know how many follow Matt Hotch on Facebook, but....

He's on his annual ride thru the mountains with his friends.  His 2017 SEUC has broken down and had to be trailered to a shop twice now.  They're not yet to the halfway point of their trip.  Internal top end motor failures... 
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: Mainecat on September 28, 2017, 03:29:40 PM
I just replaced my SE lifters that came in my stage 3 kit after 3,000 miles.  Lifter didn't fail however the chrome on the rollers were chipping off and scarring up the cam.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: J.D. on September 28, 2017, 03:52:13 PM
That isn't chrome  :'(
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: Heatwave on September 28, 2017, 04:11:53 PM
I'm surprised you guys don't know about the long time issues Harley has had with moisture in gauges (and electrical connections, turn signals, Tour Paks and bags, and other nonessential stuff).  Moisture was "leaking" into Bill's speedometer, enough to leave stains, and it had to be replaced.  It's an all too common issue, especially on a vehicle supposedly designed to be able to handle riding in inclement weather.  I'm sure the new CEO is going to insist his team finally fix this stuff.

Jerry ;)

Just had my 2017 CVO Limited Speedo replaced due to condensation leaving streaks on the inside of the gauge.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: r0de_runr on September 28, 2017, 04:37:00 PM
Just had my 2017 CVO Limited Speedo replaced due to condensation leaving streaks on the inside of the gauge. Here's the TA that addresses this issue. Unfortunately the new replacement gauge can still develop condensation. Its a known problem without a permanent resolution yet.

Imagine the sun or hot weather warming the gauge.  The air inside the gauge is pressurized because of heat expansion and slowly leaks out.  Then you hit it with the cold water and it creates a vacuum and sucks in a tiny bit of water.  My first 2007 HD did this, since then I don't spray the instruments with the hose.  And in the rain it just doesn't happen to me.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: Heatwave on September 28, 2017, 07:17:30 PM
Imagine the sun or hot weather warming the gauge.  The air inside the gauge is pressurized because of heat expansion and slowly leaks out.  Then you hit it with the cold water and it creates a vacuum and sucks in a tiny bit of water.  My first 2007 HD did this, since then I don't spray the instruments with the hose.  And in the rain it just doesn't happen to me.

But it only happens with the speedo why not the Tach? Its the same size gauge in a similar location.
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: r0de_runr on September 28, 2017, 07:31:07 PM
But it only happens with the speedo why not the Tach? Its the same size gauge in a similar location.

Good point. I dunno.  But the same question then on poor design. How is the spedo different?
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: smkymtnboy on September 28, 2017, 07:54:37 PM
I don't know how many follow Matt Hotch on Facebook, but....

He's on his annual ride thru the mountains with his friends.  His 2017 SEUC has broken down and had to be trailered to a shop twice now.  They're not yet to the halfway point of their trip.  Internal top end motor failures...
well, he has warranty! maybe, just a little embarrassment in front of his friends. oh well!! :oops:
Title: Re: Lifter collapsed on Milwaukee 8
Post by: r0de_runr on September 28, 2017, 10:26:41 PM
well, he has warranty! maybe, just a little embarrassment in front of his friends. oh well!! :oops:

You probably know this but anyway....When I took my son with me on a 9 day trip to Utah and Arizona every day was very important.  Any time spent broke down would have ruined a vacation 8 years in the making.  He and I went before he joined the Army and he went to Afghanistan.  He an LEO now and this was our first opportunity to ride together.

Some times a breakdown is more than a inconvenience. This trip he was on my Bonneville,I on my 12 CVO SG which broke the shift lever in Monument Valley.  We babied it but kept riding.

Lifter failure in 2017 is just unforgivable.