2x on the satisfaction of the Russell Day-Long (RDL) saddle.
I had one made for my 2009 Ultra Classic that I have also used on my 2014 Ultra Limited and now 2015 CVO Road Glide Ultra. I prefer it over the stock seats and my passenger (the wife) REALLY loves it. The leather matches up to the OEM materials, so only change what you need.
I had the passenger backrest done because the wife wanted to sit more straight-up. Also, I had them cut out a notch in my lumbar area so that my adjustable backrest could easily fold down flat...makes mounting/dismounting the bike much easier.
Be advised the RDL seat will sit you a little higher on the bike and does take a little getting used to when stopping. You can ask them to cut it down a little, but it will compromise the seat support somewhat. Depending on your seat height, you may also want to change your windshield and handlebars. I've gotten by with only windshield swaps.
Lastly, the passenger seat is larger and about 1" taller than most H-D seats, so you may need to make some adjustments to the tourpak. On my 1999 Ultra Classic, I needed the tourpak relocation kit to push it back and raise it a little. The Rushmore bikes can easily adjust to accommodate.
The RDL folks are great to work with, but try your best to get it right the first time, as it gets expensive shipping the seat back and forth. Oh, one more thing - I used a donor pan and back-rest so that when it came time to sell/trade the bike, I could easily swap back to OEM and take the RDL to the new bike. You can pick up scuffed or ripped seats fairly cheap on Craigslist or eBay.