Gidday Y'all,
For my Two Bob'sworth.... (20c or two bits is a near enough exchange rate),
Like most folks on here I have ridden both with and without fairings and definitely prefer to have one especially when doing the miles between the 'corners' as Ed mentioned. In my early days, before I could afford to buy a HD I rode K2 750 fours and a long line of Z900s & Z1000s most of which had bikini' fairings and they all moved with the bars. I don't know if I got much value out of the fairings and didn't really think about it to tell the truth. I changed to HDs in 85 & have had lots of fairing/screens on them since then including batwings starting with a 78 shovelhead EG Classic, I even imported an aftermarket batwing for my 99 RoadKing classic which I ran for a few years until I bit the bullet and got an EG Ultra which I kept until I moved to the far North of the world in South Louisiana.
In Oz we did not get Road Glides (unless it was a private import) until very recently, maybe 4 years ago. We did have the old FLHS (father or very close friend of Road Glides mother perhaps?) which in my experience, anyone who had one ripped the fairing straight off, bought an aftermarket headlight and tried the make the gauges look 'normalish'. Generally they were the cheapest option for a dresser and were an entry point for the bigger bikes for many.
I first tried a Road Glide while doing some riding in the states with some mates prior to moving over and did not like it at all. Figured I would never buy or ride one again and was seriously uncharitable in my description of them for some time afterwards, My poor impression was no doubt due to taking it straight down the very steep decline at the end of Yosemite closest to Death Valley without doing any flat or straight riding to get used to the whole unnatural feel of the fairing not moving with the bars deal.
A good mate in Oz bought one and convinced me to give them another try. We hired one out of Vegas for a long day's riding and I was surprised by how much I liked it after getting some 'settling in' time before trying anything overly challenging. In fact I liked it so much I bought Bertha my first CVO, (a 2011 RGU) and enjoyed every minute on her. We did all sorts of riding, highway, two lanes, mountains, dirt (not by choice), hills, mountains, deserts, and the 4 corners of Florida! by day and night, wet, dry, windy, whatever, mostly two up and very quickly decided we had been very clever as the Road glide was a good fit for us.
We did put Daymakers on Bertha as there were some visibility issue looking through some of the tight corners at night but I don't think my batwings were any better and I put spotties on them all. For me the extra light was primarily to see the critters on the edges of the road before they became interactive but it is nice to see where you are going if possible.
Lucille has been with us for about 2 years now and IMHO the improvements brought with the Rushmore bikes make a world of difference. Great handling compared to many bikes I have owned or ridden in all kinds of situations. We have experienced a similar range of riding and once again I have put some spotties on the fairing lowers to light up the edges of the road for night riding. Its still mostly for the critters as I have no intention of doing any close range critter gawking again. Had my fill of it with a bastard kangaroo about my height.
I have ridden a couple batwings since switching to the sharks and while I still enjoy them they are no longer my preferred ride as I miss the lighter front end and I can't see myself going back.
I agree with the earlier poster, the best advice is go ride anything you are considering in as many conditions s possible. Hire each one for a day or two and give it a whirl. At the end of the day you should buy Whatever Blows Your Hair Back!
Cheers Tom
PS I may have put a dollar's worth in this time.