It is my understand that Harley has stopped supplying pre-2014 Tour Paks. I am looking at used and aftermarket. I have found a local painter that I believe can match my Obsidian Gray well enough.
where did you get the idea that they aren't supplying pre-2014? they are still in the 2020 parts and accessories catalog.
there is an argument to be made for the newer style, they do hold a bit more and do have a more 'modern' look to them. but, if you don't have to have that, nothing wrong with the pre rushmore either. i just had my 2012 tour pack repainted in vivid black so i can use it on my 2019 rgs. yeah, it isn't the latest and greatest, but i only use it a couple of times per year so i'm okay with that.
also, when you compare the cost of an advanblack tour pack to the cost of factory hd, cvo paint notwithstanding, there is not much of a delta between them. especially if you use the aftermarket mounting systems with the hd pack. for example, a chopped (though king is the same cost) tour pack for my wife's bike has an msrp of $849. i can get it from a discounter for $706. the same one from advanblack is $769. but it does come with the backrest while the hd one i would have to add that. for the difference in cost, i would go with genuine hd.