Wondering also about the Jacksonville area as my bride works for the mayo clinic and could transfer there, is it as bad an area as I have heard? Not hijacking this thread to bad I hope!
As a 20 year Jacksonville resident that moved from the Baltimore Washington area, I would be very interested in what 'bad' stuff you have heard. The area definitely is not Chicago, Atlanta, Washington DC, Baltimore Richmond, Detroit.
Like many locations there are good areas and not so good areas. I am sure if you are interested in a $200k plus residence it won't be in one of the bad areas.
As for the areas to the north of Jacksonville that are mentioned, there are lots of reasons why you would want to be careful in your due dilligence.
If Jacksonville ends up on your short list, there are numerous new planned communities springing up between Jacksonville and St. Augustine that you would want to explore.
I would also suggest you consider that being near as opposed to on the coast is good for the afternoon breezes and cooler temperatures. The center of Florida is much hotter and the air doesn't flow as well as being near the coast.
Obviously everybody doesn't like the same things, colors or locations so in the end it is your choice. I would suggest renting in a area you like or at least staying there for a week or two before buying.
Good hunting.
A good thing about