Even though you think you keep your air pressure correct, have you ever checked you tire pressure gauge to see if it is correct?
I was having the same problem on my 06 running Metzlers. I was only getting 6k miles out of the rear and cupping. When I had the tire before last changed I was talking to the guy at the tire shop (not HD)and he asked me the question about my tire pressure gauge, he said there was no question in his mind I was running under inflated.
When he finished the tire he showed me with 3 didgital gauges that he checks against a pressure calibrator that the new tire was set 39.8 to 40.2, depending which gauge he used. So call it 40. I went directly to the auto parts & bought 2 new digital gauges, different brands & checked the tire right there. One read 38.8 the other read 40. I went in & returned the 38.8, got another and it read 39.7 close enough.
When I got home I checked the tire, it had been in the back of my SUV all afternoon in Phoenix, HOT, and it now read 41. I checked it with my gauge I had been using for the last several years, a $40 analog gauge, and it read 35lbs.
So the tire guy was right, I religiously cheked my tires and set them to 35lbs because of the gauge.
The lat Metzler i took off went 7200 mlies with no cupping, I could have gotten another 1k out of it because it wasn't quite at the wear bars but we were leaving on a trip.
So tire gauge, tire gauge, tire gauge
