How many miles on the Tensioner??
Are you rotating the Chain to check it at its "tightest" spot??
HD Tech told me to check / set the Chain tension at the tightest spot, cold,,, like after setting all night,,,
Got 18,500 on tensioner, that goes for the hole bike.
In my research it was stated that,.....The HD auto tensioner can/ may over tighten the primary chain do to hard acceleration and deceleration then back onto hard acceleration again, that I must admit I'm guilty of playing with some power shifting now and then and some throttle cracking which I can see now that maybe why the tensioner got ratcheted up so tight that there was no free play when I first checked it you could play a D note on it.
I'll be be putting it back together tomorrow and do another start up and see if it will tighten up any more being cold before I button it all up. It's at about 3/8 to 1/2" play on self adjustment now.