I did the chrome inner, I can see a cover a mile away. But i'll say this, the HD starter cover is way smooth.
Dave, hope you didn't need a dremel to get those reflectors off. 
How'd you like doing the hottoppers? fun
you could always add some LED's just sayin 
I couldn't tell a bike from a parking meter at a mile away...but like I said, the normal Joe doesn't know the difference, but I can tell, and I'm okay with that. I'd rather have the real thing, but this way sure was easy and inexpensive and nobody really ever seems to look at the left side of the bike anyway...probably because I don't have a centerstand. If I ever have any work done that requires removal of the primary cover, that would be the time I would change to a real one, and not have to eat all of that labor time. That's when I had it done on my last bike. Then I can sell the cover I have to some other cheap bastard.
How else do you get those reflectors off without the dremel tool? I had to make 4 horizontal cuts and then one long vertical cut, and then peel off each piece individually. Isn't that how everyone does it? The hard part was getting the bike clamped down in my vise.
The hopttoppers were kind of fun...I kept finding more places I could put them for about 4 days...and I still have about 40 of them left over...but that's because I have all of the chrome covers on the transmission and I had already done the rocker cover bolts. I found some good spots for some of them that aren't in the instructions either. I didn't like that I had to use the silicone for so many, but they are staying on. I can't believe how much of a difference those things make. It really looks awesome now. I did a few more things at the same time, so I'll have to update the photos once again soon.
The LED's are a distinct possibility, but I'm not in any hurry since I don't have the bike out after dark too often. I'll probably do the Xenon headlamp before I think too hard about the LED's on the engine.
In case anyone actually took me serious about removing the reflectors, no, I didn't really use a dremel tool. I got out the chainsaw for a job that size. Seriously, the fishing line worked great and I had all 4 off and tape cleaned up inside of 10 minutes.