Had a trip up to Maine last week so I stopped by a my local Cigar shop and picked up a Padron, a Punch, a 3 pak of Macanudo ( Robusto, Cafe, and Maduro ) and a handful of some brand I never heard of that the shopkeeper said was a good priced, solid smoke - Flor de Oliva. I also got a guillotine cutter - much better than the scissor and knifes I had been using. The Punch was probably my least favorite, though not bad by any means, the Padron I truly enjoyed as I did all three of the Macanudo's, especially the Maduro. The kicker was I really, really liked the off brand Flor de Oliva, unbelievably even the girlfriend likes these and the smell also - which makes life better. I still think I might like the Monte Cristo's the best followed by these. These are 5x50 - which I assume is 5" with a 50 ring gauge, seems a tad big but not bad. From reading the cutting tips, it seems I haven't cut enough off. What are the reasons behind the "punch a hole" method? I need to get a humidor, figured I'd be ok for now in the garage and truck cupboards as I they have been pretty close to 70/70 but that won't last. When you put them in the Humidor should they be removed from the individual plastic wrappers?