Bribe36, if you're looking for someone to tell you definitely buy it or definitely don't buy it, you may as well just flip a coin. You will find examples where folks have come out ahead by having an ESP, and you will find many more where folks haven't recouped the investment. As a general statement, the majority do not receive full value for ESP's on any product. These things are big profit makers for the folks selling and administering them, which by definition means they pay out much less in claims than they take in. So the question becomes, how can I tell if I'll be one of those who saves money by purchasing an ESP or if I'll be one of those who just threw a grand or more down a rat hole? And I don't know a single person who can honestly answer that question. You have to look at your own situation, weigh the odds, and then place your bet. It's not much different than walking into a casino.
BTW, personally I never buy an ESP and I estimate that I've saved over $20k in 35 years. In fact, I've only owned one vehicle and one appliance that required any kind of major repair that would have been covered if I had in fact bought the ESP. So while I can't say what your or my experience will be on any one particular purchase, I can say that over many years the odds are you will save more by skipping ESP's. Now, having said all that, if I were buying a current model CVO and I could get the ESP for around $1200 or so, I believe I might break tradition and buy it. There are just too many quality and reliability issues with the recent products from the MoCo, and I believe those issues may skew the odds fairly heavily against a troublefree ownership experience. JMHO
Jerry