There's 3 or 4 dozen testimonials to Clearview Shields on this site (see vendor discounts and service). That'll be my next purchase.
I've run stock H-D shield, Clearview and KW. The Clearview is hands down the most effective AND quiet shield I have personally used. I had an oversized Clearview I sold that was almost like being in an enclosed vehicle it blocked the wind so well, but I didn't like looking through it so I sold it and bought a 14" which is perfect.
As I understand it, the Klockwerks shield is intended to work as an airfoil more than a windscreen. Testing by KW has shown a 10% increase in downforce on the front end of a motorcycle using the product. I don't believe the KW is marketed as a long distance windshield. The problem folks are having with the KW's may well be in what they THINK it is supposed to do vice what the Klock family designed them to do. Bear in mind, this product came about as a result of land speed record attempts by the Klock family at Bonneville
Anyway, if you want quiet, dry, windless protection, call up Clearview and give them the details on your height, inseam etc that will help them recommend the perfect size for you.
B B