I bought a Pitbull MC lift for my 05 SEEG four years ago. Somewhat heavy, but really well made with heavy duty wheels and all moving joints and wheels have fittings to grease them which will help prevent rust.
The grease fittings sound like a definite plus

i have been using an aluminum jack on my 05 SEEG for almost four years. just took delivery of an 09 UCSE4 and it did not work. started up and then wanted to tip over! not cool. went to a bike show a couple of weeks ago and talked with the pit bull guys. just waiting for it to come in. well worth the 400 bucks. remember, you have an expensive bike, don't put it on a cheap lift!!!!!!!! 
I could not agree more!

Couldn't agree more about getting a reliable jack that can carry the load safely. Pitbull is excellent and they also make a shop dolly on wheels if you want to get it off the floor during the winter, although I am not sure if keeping it suspended all winter would cause any suspension problems in the spring, but it sure would make it easier to move around the garage.
I have no idea about the suspension, may be a good question for the service techs/manager.

I have the red Sears lift and it works just fine with my 09 SEUG. I'm not really happy with using the lift for oil changes because it makes it difficult to get to the drain plugs and to position a catch pan under the stream. I'm thinking of buying a wheel chock or a flip-stand or a scissor jack for oil changes.
The J&S lift offered an optional oil drain insert that sat in the middle of the lift, and the oil would run down off of that angled piece into your drain pan on the floor (I least that's how I took that it worked)

I have the J&S for my 09 SERG and it fits/works fine. Should be same for yours. After 3 uses, the hydrualic jack sprung an oil leak. was replaced no questions asked, but it made me wonder.
Kinda makes ya go hmmmm

. Good to know that they stood behind it and replaced it. Any problems since then and how many uses since then?

i think the bottom line will always be, whatever works for you and your confortable with. my better half had bought me the lift from SEARS and was a little upset with the pit bull rep, for saying your putting a 40K bike on a $100 lift. so when i got home WE put it under the bike and SHE DIDN'T feel confortabole. she said the Pit Bull was allot wider and made the bike rest better. case closed. she won and i got a new lift

Sounds like your better half is a definite keeper!

Thanks for all the input!

I've seen many good comments on both products. Has anyone needed service from the Pitbull folks, and if so, how did that go?
I think the pitbull is about $80 more than the J&S, and the pitbull goes up $70 on March 1 (at least their site says there's currently a $70 off sale until Feb. 28, but you never know what to believe or what's coming next or if that Feb. 28 date will automatically change to Mar. 31).
I did email J&S to make sure they said it fits the '09 frame and they said it does. A little more research and time to pull the trigger. I'm supposed to finally get my bike by the end of next week

Right Ride on, UpChuck82