1st off why not repair the damaged fairing ? You're talking a top notch shop that can color match ; a very small amount of fine body filler, sand,paint and color sand plus clear over paint work.
Beyond that we live in an age where the super rich flaunt their wealth in the faces of everyone. How many shows are there on the tube about people who have so much and are so arrogant. It's no wonder to me we've got people walking the streets with a chip on their shoulders who do stuff like key or in this case take a Buck to a new $40k H-D or those who simply take (steal) whatever it is they want. It would seem there is a whole generation (if not two) that have not been exposed to solid middle class people who get a yearn for something nice, work hard, save and finally aquire whatever it is they wanted. You certainly don't see a reality show about honest hard working middle class folks. Even the shows the feature the goings on in Sturgis, Daytona etc don't spend even one second of air time discussing how the average H-D owner aquires his bike.
Lastly, I am sorry for this. Sorry because of the way you felt when you discovered it. Sorry about how it makes you feel about people in general and sorry that as a society we've gotten to where something like this isn't an anomoly, it's fairly common. I hope you get everything worked out and somehow manage to hang onto your faith in - - -if not your fellow man, then at least your H-D brothers and sisters
B B