I'm glad that you've had positive experiences with warranty work, and also that you had what sounds like a positive experience when talking to the Engineers. Unfortunately, they are not the ones who get to decide what, if any, improvements might be made...but, that is the nature of the beast, and I understand that. I have absolutely no problem with companies making money, but I don't thing anyone can say that HD is not making a pretty penny off a 36K motorcycle...no other production motorcycle that I'm aware of costs that much. And we pay it without complaint, but do expect the highest level of quality for that amount of money. I don't think that is an unreasonable expectation.
Again, outside looking in...
When a man buys the top of the line CVO Harley for $35,000+, is it unreasonable for him to expect
not to have issues that need to be fixed under warranty? The last motorcycle to have issues should be the CVO because the high price of admission should be a guarantee that the bike is factory's best effort.
I bought a Suzuki VL1500 in 2001. Brand new, zero miles, $8500. When I sold that bike it had the original battery and even all the original light bulbs were still working. 65,000 miles of flogging that thing with nothing but routine maintenance, without a single failure of any kind, and the bike was never back at the dealership for anything. Not a bash against HD, but speaking in general, if an $8500 Japanese pot-metal POS motorcycle can give that sort of service and reliability, then a $35K+ American made factory custom should do at least as well.
Voided the warranty on the Victory 3 months after I bought it by modifying the engine and didn't care. Still, all it ever needed was a voltage regulator in the 48K miles I've ridden it. I did have a head gasket fail, but that wasn't the manufacturer's fault. I would say 11:1 compression and twenty eight 1/4-mile passes in the 100 degree heat
might have had something to do with that.
You guys who ponied up the big bucks for the flagship models shouldn't feel guilty about demanding a high quality machine.