Don't misunderstand me...I'm not dissing Progressive. It is an alternative, and MUCH better than stock. The cartridge is gas charged, but it is inside a fork tube that has oil in it, and uses the stock bushings and seals (there is no other choice...Traxxion does the same thing). The bushings have some sort of coating on them, and they wear, contaminating the oil. Not to mention that the springs are rubbing the inside of the fork tubes, causing additional particles to contaminate the oil. Traxxion reccomends a "service" at 20-25K, and pulling the cartridge out at 40-45K to check for wear on the components. I don't know what the regular service costs, but it's in line with a regular fork service, if done properly, which means replacing the bushings and in all likelyhood, the seals. Pulling the forks is the main cost, because of the labor involved, but that is the case no matter what's inside the tubes. Progressive warranties their cartridges for life, but you still have to get them out of the forks for replacement/rebuilding, and they WILL fail at some point in time, just like the shocks. Nothing lasts forever, no matter who makes it. Shocks are easy to take off and send back, but fork servicing is a different ballgame. Suspension wear happens slowly over time, so goes unnoticed until it is practically worn out. The stock HD stuff is crap to begin with, and is total chit by 20K, front and rear. But people ride on it with tens of thousands of miles on the stock stuff...that doesn't mean they should, just that they do, because they have no basis for comparison. I've ridden a bike with the Progressive Monotubes and it is far better than stock. I have also owned three bikes, and ridden others, that have the Traxxion components in the front end. For me, there is no comparison. You get what you pay for in most cases. I choose what I want, and some do nothing, or make other choices. I have no vested interest either way.