The operative phrase in Muddy's question was "Virginia bike insurance". What is the cheapest or best in one state is often not a great deal in another state, since most companies set rates based on claim history in each state. For instance, Progressive used to be the cheapest and best bike insurance in Indiana for many years, and then overnight they became one of the most expensive. When I questioned the huge increase, it was explained that they had experienced a big increase in claims and costs in Indiana and thus the rates had to go up. I went with Foremost for a few years, and they were fine, but then they started that same "rate creep" and now I'm with GEICO.
If you watch all the ads on TV you might notice that each and every major company claims they will cut your premiums by hundreds if you switch. Think about that for a moment, and you should be able to see through that BS pretty easily. At the same time State Farm, for instance, is offering you a $400 better rate to switch from GEICO, GEICO is offering a $400 better rate to folks to change from State Farm to them. DUH!
Anyhow, these days you can get quotes online from most of the big name insurer's, and that's what I would recommend Muddy. Go to the websites of the major insurance companies and get a quote from each, just make sure they are all for the same coverage amounts. Some tend to default to state minimum coverage limits to make their price look much better. Or find a good independent agent and let him do all the research for you.
Jerry