I can't compare the new 4" Rhineharts, but can compare the 3.5" that I had on my '06 SEUC to the Fullsac X pipe and 2" cores with packing left in the cans. The Rhineharts were much louder. Not obnoxious, but too loud, IMO. They sounded great, but after a full day on the road, even with a Flip Face helmet, my ears were ringing. Not good...
I do not want anything louder than the 2" cores...they still "sound like a Harley", whatever that means to each individual, but my ears don't ring at the end of the day, and when you get on the throttle, they bark a good bit. At idle/cruise, they are just right for me. And, they are not so loud as to offend other, non-motorcyclists...if you act right. If we don't want noise legislation shoved down our throats, we all better start paying more attention to how much noise we make, and where.
Every Thunderheader I've ever heard is obnoxiously loud...setting off car alarms tends to piss people off.