I have the same bike, similar mods and also have a Power Commander, my numbers are right in line with yours also, unless the moon is full and the stars are all aligned!
Like someone has suggested, you can get the same bike getting different results, sometimes it can just depend on the weather!
I agree with the others here... especially when it comes to the dyno and tuning... but I doubt you'd climb up to 12 ft lbs with just a gasket change, I don't think you'd get that much if you even milled the head too... but half the fun is opening it up and playing around... I always worry about what I'll find this time though!