You are correct and I stand to be corrected.....all the boot topics are old. And when I said "it's been beat to death" I didn't mean that the way it may have been construed. I apologize if it was taken wrong.
There's a reason law enforcement and fire fighters wear Original Swat....super lightweight, super comfortable, excellent traction and your feet stay dry even when you're standing in water.
The down side.....because the inner and outter soles are so soft, they wear out in a year.
The up side....at $85 a pair on Amazon and for this kind of comfort you can afford to replace them yearly.

I suggest, for your first pair, go with the Original Swat 9" Classic side zip. For winter time you may want to look at the Original Swat 9" Tactical (they're also side zip).