I purchased a 2009 street glide last October with 4,200 on it with the stock tires on it. The original owner ran the front tire low on air pressure and the outer edges had minor cupping due to the low pressure. I replaced it this spring with an Dunlop American Elite and the rear tire appeared ok.
At 7,000 miles I started hearing a howl coming from the rear of the bike and I thought that it might be coming from the belt or the tire. It was not the belt and the tire had minimal wear at that point.
We just returned from a 2,000 mile trip to the Michigan UP and it got much worse as we were 2 up and heavily loaded. It was noticeably cupped and I ordered a new AE from my indy shop and I put it on the bike yesterday. The front AE tire has about 4,000 miles on it and it looks excellent.
It has plenty of cornering stick and there is no noise at all on cornering. I will have to see how it works in the wet and what the total mileage will be. The stock HD Dunlop has 9,800 miles on it and it appears that it would have went to 15,000 miles, but the howling and the fact that it was 7 years old made my decision.
My local indy shop has had excellent results with both the Dunlop AE and the Michelin Commander II tires on his Harley customer bikes.