Here's my take on this. Everybody's right. Here's why. For most riding, the 12" KW will do you fine and just looks soooooooooo cool. If you've seen one of these on a Road Glide it is as significant a styling addition as saddlebag spoilers, a nice seat, you name it. They make the RG look finished in a way no other windshield does. However as mentioned, they do create turbulence issues that for me personally have not proven to be an issue on short rides (under 200 miles) but I would agree would be annoying riding all day long. Therefore, if you're going on a long trip, then there's no doubt the Clearview (size dependant on your personal HumEng factors) can't be beat. As with anything else, there is no one size fits all. If you're not running the H-D Chrome trim (which I decided after awhile I don't care for) then you can swap out a winshield in 10 minutes. And H-D sells a nice cotton lined canvas bag to store the one you're not using in. Hang it from a hook out of the way in your garage and your shield will always be scratch free.
B B