Pledge - tried it and it shined the bike real nice, but it was in incredible dust magnet.
Maguire's - I've been using that for a while and happy with the results. I've now put that aside due to the results with ICE listed below.
ICE - I tried it on my SUV a few times and never hated a wax so much. I noticed how nice the shine was on a friend's bike and asked him what he used. He uses ICE and he told me that it was imperative to let it dry fully before removing it. I tried it on the bike, which I had never tried before, and wow, what a great shine and easy to work with. I found that I can put a good coat on a lot of the bike to give it time to dry, and then go back to the beginning to start removal, and it really does leave a very wet looking shine.
GLARE - I've never tried it yet, but as many times as I've seen nothing but praise about it on this site over the past few years, I see no choice but to give it a whirl. I know my local Honda dealers keep it in stock and one dealer's prices are much better than the others...luckily the closest dealer to my house.