To answer you, yes you are wrong, drop a gear and grab a handful of throttle. This is the strangest thread I have ever seen. How to ride??? What?? RPM Makes power, more RPM the better.
You are very misinformed if you believe that more RPM = more power on a Harley big twin. This might be true for much smaller-displacement Asian inline fours - but it is definitely NOT true for large-displacement Harley V-twins. Harley V-Twins produce a lot of low-RPM torque, whereas Asian inline fours produce very low torque but lots of HP at very high RPM. They are totally different engine philosophies.
The maximum power band (in RPM) for your Harley V-Twin engine depends entirely on your engine build - your intake, your CAMS, your compression ratio, your exhaust, and your TUNE. All of these things affect where your engine makes the most total power. This will, in the vast majority of all street cases, very likely be below 5252 RPM - the torque/RPM crossover point. Unless you have an absolutely monster HP race build, you will very likely be making
less total power at
greater than 5252 RPM than you will be at
under 5252 RPM. Most Harley street engines running typical "street" cams are "all in" at some point under 5252 RPM, and the torque starts dropping off faster than the HP is building - thus the engines is making less total power at the higher RPM, no more. If you are running very high-lift/high-duration cams, have race-ported heads, very high compression, etc...you may see total power increase up to even 6000 RPM - but probably 99% of all Harley street bikes do not fit this ultra high-performance profile.
As I said - once you are past the point at which the torque produced by the engine is falling at a rate which exceeds the rate at which the RPM is rising, you need to upshift to continue to accelerate at the maximum rate the engine can provide. HP = Torque * RPM / 5252, and there is no escaping this simple equation...
You need to keep the engine in the proper gearing that will enable it to make its maximum power - and that gearing varies greatly from bike to bike, depending on your specific build.
But go ahead, rev your big V-Twin up to redline, see what happens to your acceleration rate. It will likely plummet. You will accomplish nothing other than tearing up your engine, and likely throwing a rod or bending a valve due to valve float...
Ken