Welcome to the "cupping" club.
Even though I purchased this bike used, my Dealer hooked me up with a new front tire under the recall.
As Jerry posted, there are no other options in the proper size /
load range for the '09 SERGs at this time. (hint to Michelin)
'Installed the HD Premium Suspension (f & r), the rear tire still cupped...
'Ran across some Vehicle Dynamics Engineers (Chrysler) at a Roadhouse in Kingman, AZ last fall (Chrysler shares the same Proving Grounds with HD just a bit South of Kingman), showed them the bike, explained the issues, and after some deliberation (they bought us a few more beers

) they told me to "Try firming up the Left (Drive) side of the bike." 'Made sense to me, so I installed the GlidePro bushings and went to 41 psi in the rear, and the cupping was actually reversed ~ I know, I was surprised too! that the cupping was actually reversed!.
Keeping the rear at 41psi is probably the best cost/benefit.