foremost ask ultrafxr!! [smiley=xyxthumbs.gif]
I can definitely recommend Foremost since they replaced my totaled out 2006 melon with a brand new 2007 Jester. But I think some other companies have the same or similar deal - if your bike is totaled during the first two years and you've been insured with us since day one, yada, yada, yada, then we'll buy you a new one. Doubt they get called on this very often but it did work out for me.
With that said (and I plan to stick with Foremost) I've had several other carriers. No tickets, no accidents, no claims until this recent crash. Funny that the first year's premium with Progressive and Dairyland was quite good but then the renewal was awful. What changed? I dunno. Like I said no claims, no tickets, no accidents. Go figure.
Rates are very, very dependent on where you live. And not just your metro area but your actual zip code. I was in an unincororated area several years ago. Did not move but came in to the city limits of a nearby town and my zip code changed. Rates went down substantially.
You just gotta shop around.