Actually there is a third type of Harley rider, the ones that never ride, just sit them in a garage. HD's favorite. As you will certainly here a few more times, the oil requirement is pure BS. When I tried the Lemon law with the failing 2nd motor in my 07 SERK, HD also said I caused the famous oil leak by changing the slip on mufflers. I have it in writing. As far as the Lemon Law, each state is different, but for autos as well they have an expected life in mileage clearly stated. In MA. I believe it is 20,00 miles, which means if you win, it is prorated based on your mileage versus the stated expected life. Some states have higher mileage, some lower.
What you wrote is why I'll keep buying older bikes, better quality, and not worrying about a useless warranty. BTW, the 110 motor can't be fixed by HD under warranty, only parts replaced that fail do to poor design and poor quality.
I cant agree more.
People on this site are the exception to that rule.
Most people I know that have bikes are lucky to put 1,000 miles a year on there bike and MOCO knows that.
Thats why I find myself riding alone a lot, they are to busy cleaning them or bragging to everyone that they have one.
But never seem to ride it.
We all put a lot of miles are our bikes and certainly put them through there paces more then most.
I do believe that is why we report more failures.
As for them doing so much warranty work! (IF THEY MADE A BETTER PRODUCT IT WOULDN'T BE A f*&^IN PROBLEM, WOULD IT).

I think its an utter shame the way they are treating you and it upsets me to no end.
I have worked for GM Dealers in the past and have seen the same type of problems with them not wanting to warranty stuff.
But usually if the customer yelled loud enough it would get done, not sure if MOCO is the same.
Its a tough decision for all of us.
They tell us not to alter there bikes but to truly enjoy them we must, due to the EPA restrictions. (Damn shame)
I have not even got my FLHTCUSE6 home yet and I pretty much have been told be the Dealer that the MOCO may not warranty my bike due to modifications already made.
I figure its a crap shoot anymore, I got lucky with my last 2 bikes. 2004 FXDWG, we built the motor and put 84,000 hard miles on it before I sold it with no problems.
Then we put cams and some other stuff in my FLHTCUSE3 and put over 40,000 miles on it with only the head gasket recall done and no other problems.
So hopefully I will have he same luck with this one, and if not I will try my hardest too make them fix the problem(provided my modification did not cause the problem). Haha
I was going to purchase an older bike like some of you mentioned.
But I was so excited about the new frame design so I went with the new one.
I will tell you all this, it will be my last new bike.
And if the motor does fail, I will deal with it somehow.
Best of luck to you, but what ever happens please don't let them make you scared to ride you bike.'

Run it, have fun, if it lets go have it fixed your way and never worry again.
Dave