I have been a member since 2003, so anything prior to that I cannot speak of. I can agree that there is drama sometimes in chapters, but there is drama everywhere. Being in America, if you don't want to be in a local chapter, don't. Good chapters are a reflection on good dealer/sponsors.
I went Life last year and just got my renewal packet last week. Yea, this year's design isn't that good. With it came the 2012 Adventure Guide. Now this probably cost quite a bit to print and mail to all members, and most likely is an attempt to publicize the benefits. My membership does have it's privelages. There have been new benefits added in the past few years. AT&T, Best Western to name two. If you don't like the benefits, don't be a member. Remember we live in America.
It was said here that it seems "hokey". And maybe you are right, but a better marketing and business model is not out there. Be a member, ride and have fun, get services, new tires, new bike, etc...... BRILLIANT! Honda, Kawasaki, BMW, Susuki, Ford, GM, etc have not been able to copy it.
I have been the Director for the local chapter, have been on the State Rally committees and participated in many, many rides and events. I miss the national rallies for all the same reasons others have said here.
I think the bottom line up front is that with restructering and the economy, it would be criminal to the stock holders for the MoCo to not do what they can to keep the company a float and strong.
Just my .02
Yoda